This vegan egg salad sandwich is even easier to make than a traditional egg salad! It takes just 10 minutes to whip up and only 7 ingredients are needed. No fussing about with boiling, cooling, and peeling eggs. A super easy and super tasty lunchtime favourite- veganized. No stinky eggs and cholesterol-free!
The key ingredient in this vegan egg salad sandwich recipe is black salt which is also called kala namak. This is what provides the egg flavour in all of my egg recipes including my vegan fried egg, vegan egg yolk, tofu scramble spice mix, and deviled potatoes. Yum!
Black salt (which is actually pink in colour) tastes and smells just like eggs! It’s so very strange and cool. You can buy black salt (kala namak) at Indian grocery stores or you can order black salt on Amazon here.
Once you have the black salt this recipe is so quick in easy you can whip it up in a pinch, or make the vegan egg salad filling ahead of time for lunch another day. Serve along with some veggies and hummus, or (my fave) some salty potato chips.
Let me tell you, tasting this sandwich is like the ultimate throwback to my before vegan days. It reminds me of being a kid and enjoying lunch with my grandma on a summer day. Isn’t it nice that we can recreate those taste memories?
To make the vegan egg salad sandwich:
Chop the tofu into a small cube. For the best result, make sure you use medium-firm tofu which has the most egg-like consistency.
Add the tofu to a large bowl along with the vegan mayonnaise, nutritional yeast, yellow mustard, green onions, black salt, and turmeric. Gently mix. If desired add table salt and pepper to taste. You can store it covered in the fridge for 2 – 3 days or enjoy right away!
When ready to enjoy, toast the bread if desired. Layer a slice of bread with a lettuce leaf and then follow with a generous serving of the vegan egg salad. Top with the remaining slice of bread and serve.
Bon appetegan!
Sam.
Only 10 minutes to make and it tastes just like eggs! Perfect for a quick lunch. Make this salad ahead of time for meal prep.
- 1 block (454g) medium-firm tofu, drained and patted dry
- 6 tablespoons vegan mayonnaise
- 2 tablespoon nutritional yeast
- 2 teaspoon yellow mustard
- 2 green onions, chopped
- 3/4 teaspoon black salt
- 1/4 teaspoon turmeric
- salt and pepper to taste (optional)
- 8 slices bread (gluten-free if preferred)
- 4 lettuce leaves
To make the vegan egg salad: chop the tofu into a small cube. Add the tofu to a large bowl along with the vegan mayonnaise, nutritional yeast, yellow mustard, green onions, black salt, and turmeric. Gently mix. If desired add table salt and pepper to taste.
To make vegan egg salad sandwiches: toast the bread if desired. Layer 4 slices of bread with a lettuce leaf and then follow with a generous serving of the vegan egg salad. Top with the remaining slices of bread and serve.
*Nutrition is based on one serving of the vegan egg salad without bread and lettuce. One serving is 1/4th of the recipe.
*Vegan egg salad can be made ahead of time and stored covered in the fridge for 2 - 3 days. If it looks watery, just give it a gentle stir to reincorporate.
Nutrition
Did you make this recipe?
Tag @itdoesnttastelikechicken on Instagram and hashtag #itdoesnttastelikechicken.
Has anyone made this within the nutritional yeast?
I am not totally Vegan, mostly a wannabe, and am in constant pursuit of recipes to support my conviction to completely “crossover” to the Vegan side. So when I saw this recipe, I was drawn to it because I need to know I will not miss out on egg salad sandwiches! I need to pick up the black salt, because you stated it will make it taste like eggs, which sounds wonderful! I love your introductory video, showing how you grew up in a meat eating family. I am convinced your website will allow me to explore many wonderful Vegan recipes and make the switch…perhaps as suddenly as you did. Thanks!
Aww that’s wonderful! I hope you enjoy many of my recipes, Millican 🙂
So good! I love everything on this website and this egg salad probably the most and my non-veggie boyfriend loved it even more! I didn’t have black salt so I replaced it with pink Himalayan salt and white pepper.
Glad you enjoyed! Black salt (kala namak) will make the sandwich taste like egg, so I recommend you pick some up.
I despise tofu more times than not so I was really hesitant about this recipe but for some odd reason I’ve been craving egg salad. I fully expected a mouthful of disappointment but whoa. I’m mind blown. This is going to be my go to recipe for Omni Cookouts this summer. Thank you so much!
Haha! Amazing. Thrilled you loved it so much, Anna 🙂
Are you freaking kidding me?! I feel like an idiot for waiting this long to buy black salt. Holy hell. I could cry tears of yolky joy right now. God bless you Sam and your eggy vegan voodoo.
Bahaha, love it!! Thanks, Danielle 🙂
Amazing and fantastic! Another simple but delicious recipe, Sam! I have to admit for the last few years I pretty much just followed Brandi Doming bc her recipes are easy and always turn out great, but I am so happy I found you through Instagram. I am highly impressed with everything I have made of yours and look forward to exploring more of your site. Thank you so much for sharing your genius recipes!
Wonderful! So happy you’re enjoying it, Colleen 🙂
This was awesome. Worth the wait for the black salt. I hanks
So happy you enjoyed!
The black salt comes in many different colours and grinds. Which would be the best to get for most purposes? I have a spice grinder and can powder it if necessary. Thanks!
Hi Gina, the finest grind would for sure be the best. It really shouldn’t range in colour tho. Make sure you’re getting the black salt that is also called kala namak. It’s actually pink in colour. It’s the only salt that has the eggy taste. Enjoy!
Super easy and delicious! My husband loved it (and he’s not easy to please!). Thanks again Sam for another tasty recipe! I’m trying the seitan chicken next!
Awesome!! I hope you love the seitan too!
This is so GOOD! I also tried it on top of crackers. I will definitely make this regularly
Yay! Thrilled you enjoyed 🙂
Well this was always going to be a tough one – I am not vegan and I absolutely love egg mayonnaise sandwiches – BUT, I made this for my son who does follow a plant based diet and I can only say WOW. It is not only delicious, and very close to the ‘real’ thing, but I think I like it even more! Sooo impressed. I used firm, but not extra firm tofu and I pressed mine before mixing it. Gorgeous!
Haha! That’s so amazing!!! Thrilled you loved it so much, Mary 🙂
Absolutely delicious! I have been craving egg salad and this hit the spot! Thank you!
Yay! Thrilled you enjoyed 🙂
This is kind of astounding. I’m trying to eat vegan as much as possible, but still cross the line every now and then. As a result, I can say I have had a “real” egg salad sandwich recently. If someone served this to me, I think I might get fooled. Thanks so much for sharing this!
Haha! Amazing! Thrilled you loved it 🙂
Amazing recipe! It’ll be in the rotation for sure from now on. I’ve made it twice now and the second time I tweaked it just a little (not the sauce, because that’s amazing, tastes exactly like eggs) I pressed my tofu to get more water out and mixed the tofu in a food processor to make more of a spread consistency and then I didn’t taste the tofu as much. This was a fantastic recipe, what a phenomenal cook you are!
Aww thanks so much, Kaley! Glad you enjoyed 🙂
The taste snd texture is spot on.
However, I found mine to be a bit too salty. What ingredient should I cut back on? I followed the directions except I didn’t add the salt to taste because it was already on the salty side. I also added a little water just to thin the sauce out a bit to make it easier to add to the tofu.
I used Hellmann’s vegan mayonnaise, French’s yellow mustard, Bob’s Red Mill nutritional yeast, and Spice Lab black salt. I don’t know if any of these brands have extra salt that is creating the extra saltiness.
I look forward to anyone’s suggestions.
Black salt is salty, so you could reduce that to taste. Enjoy!
Amazing! The nutritional yeast makes the yolky part! Pure brilliance! Cruelty free egg salad without all the cholesterol. This would fool a non vegan for sure!
So happy you enjoyed!
Very Good. Way better than anything I’ve tried yet. Made the recipe exactly as stated although I freeze my tofu then thaw it and press it until there’s very little moisture. Used: Nasoya extra firm tofu. Packaged as “397g drained weight”. It’s 300 g once I pressed all the moisture out. Added some pickle juice, diced pickles and pepper to finished salad. The black salt is absolutely NECESSARY 🙂
Well done. You’re recipes have helped me so much. Changing the world one Sam-wich at a time 😉
Haha! Amazing, so glad it was a hit, Jen 🙂
This is seriously tasty. I used 1/2 tsp black salt, a few turns on the pepper grinder and some salt-free mustard. I mixed all the “sauce” ingredients together before I added the tofu bits. I could have eaten another sandwich, but I held back. I’ll eat it for dinner instead.
Aww yay, thrilled it’s another hit for you, Jessica 🙂
So delicious! I use to love egg salad sandwiches and this tastes (and feels) amazingly similar to me and completely satisfying. Who needs eggs when you can eat this?!
P.S. This now features regularly in our lunch boxes! 🙂
Haha! Right!? Thrilled you enjoy it so much, JP 🙂
So good, was craving this so bad!
Yay! Thrilled you loved it 🙂
Hey Sam, another genuine recipe. My husband loves eggs and I used to love them pre-vegan so it was really nice to enjoy an eggy recipe together!!!! Will definitely make again. Thanks
Genius**
Hi Sam – question on the yellow mustard. Is it the dry mustard or prepared?
Prepared. 🙂
I make mine with dry mustard powder (a smaller quantity, according to mixing proportions on container) and it works just fine.
Wonderful!!! SO happy you both enjoyed! 🙂
OMG!! I am continually amazed at how authentic your recipes are Sam! This recipe just brings a whole new level to vegan! Next time I’m going to add some curry powder
Aww thanks so much, Gail!!! So happy you loved it so much 🙂
So I’ve been stalking this recipe for weeks since you first posted it. I wanted to try it SO BADLY but I was just scared I’d be disappointed. You see…I was kind of the family egg salad queen (after my Mum of course) & could devour large bowls of the cholesterol laden stuff. So when I saw this, I wanted it…like a chubby kid wants cake. No…even MORE! So today, I bit the bullet. And all I can say to myself is “oh yea of little faith…”. THIS IS MIND-BLOWING! It’s JUST like the real deal, only no death, pain, cholesterol & faffing with shells & smells & mess. I followed your recipe to the letter (‘cept a teensy bit of onion salt). HOT DANG…Sam, you’re seriously changing the vegan home cooking game. Thank you a gazillion times! x
Hahaha! I love that! So very happy this recipe didn’t let you down, Tova!! 🙂
This was so good!
My non-vegan hubby just went and made another sandwich!
P.S. Making your chili tonight… I’ve probably made it 10 times now
Haha! Love it! So thrilled you are enjoying my recipes so much, Beverly 🙂
Wonderful tasting, wonderful texture. It was indeed like I was eating my favorite egg salad sandwich that I loved as a kid! I just love your recipes! You keep them simple enough for people who are not big time cooks, while still introducing us to a new spice or food here and there to keep us interested. Being vegan is new to me this year and you have really helped me with this transition to trying to eat more homemade vs processed prepackaged vegan foods! Thank you!
Aww thank you so much, Liza! Thrilled you are enjoying my recipes so much 🙂 Congrats on your new veganism, I’m so happy I’ve been able to help you with my recipes!
Just made this for supper this evening. Honestly feel like a kid again with memories of my mom making egg salad sandwiches for my school lunches. Thanks for another winner recipe!
I love that I was able to help bring back those memories for you! So very happy you enjoyed it, Josee 🙂
As a vegan for many years, I’ve tried a ton of recipes for egg-less salad and this is by far the best. I usually add all kinds of other stuff but followed this recipe as shown and keeping to the simplicity of just a few ingredients was really the key. Thanks!
Aww wow! So glad you think so, izzi 🙂 Yes, I often feel simple is best.
Oh my. This was so so good. I added pickles and put this in a wrap and it was beyond delicious! Def going to be my go to for lazy dinners. Thanks so much!!
Yay!!! So very happy you loved it so much, Anastasia 🙂
Quick question as I am new at working with tofu …..do we need to press the water out and or cook the tofu?
Hi Liesl! I always give full instructions on how to prepare the tofu in each of my recipes, so for this recipe, all you need to do is drain off the excess water from the package and pat it dry as indicated in the recipe. No pressing needed. Enjoy!
WOW- I don’t know why I’m surprised at how spot-on the taste and texture is, because everything you do is pure magic, but this stuff is mind boggling. Thank you!
Haha!! Thank you so much, Jenny!! Thrilled you love it so much 🙂
Spot on! Thanks for a great recipe!
You’re most welcome, Stephanie! So happy you love it 🙂
Yum! Just made this for lunch and tastes just like what I remember egg salad to taste like. Only things to note for the next time I make it – the tofu really broke apart and instead of cubes ended up more like a “spread” after all the stirring. Next time I’ll make the sauce and lightly fold the tofu cubes in and/or use a different tofu brand (this one was super mushy despite being medium firm) – but was still amazing and we polished off the bowl!
If you can find super firm tofu, it works great. Or you can always press Extra firm tofu. It’s a great recipe!
So happy you enjoyed it so much, Jessica! Yes you can try a different brand of tofu and see if that results in a better texture for you. 🙂
What brand of vegan mayonnaise do you use?
Right now I’m enjoying Hellmanns but I also like to make my own using the recipe in my cookbook. Enjoy!
Hi Sam. This isn’t so much a comment as a question. Is the mustard which you add, mustard powder or what we call in UK made mustard? The outcome would be very different so I’m asking before I make a horrible mistake!
Hi Anita, it is prepared mustard not mustard powder. Enjoy!
Hi Sam,
One of the first recipes I found when I decided to go vegan was for “egg salad.” It is similar but different from yours. Therefore, I must try your recipe. But it’ll have to wait until I find black salt in my travels.
Cheers,
Bill
P.S. If plans don’t get blown up, I plan on trying out your chili recipe for dinner tonight. Since I finally used up the last of the bacon from my freezer last week, today I made your Mushroom Bacon for Sunday breakfast. Last week, I made your Mushroom Stroganoff. Keep ’em comin’!
Awesome! I hope you enjoy both recipes, Bill 🙂
This looks so good. I can’t wait to try it. I’ve pinned it. I found your blog a few weeks ago and am so glad that I did.
I’m glad you did too, Lea! Welcome 🙂
Looks SOOO good! I know what I’m having for lunch!
Yay!! I hope you love it, Cynthia 🙂